Collinsville has had many boys selected as Honorable Mention on the different All-State Teams and others listed on the All-Southern Teams. The players listed were selected to IHSA All-State Teams.
- Eddie Evers, 1936, 1937
- Melvin Richter, 1937
- Walter "Hoot" Evers, 1938
- Sam Miranda, 1948
- Ray Sonnenberg, 1948
- Norman Schaulat, 1949
- Charles Kraak, 1950
- Don Deterding, 1952
- Jack Hanvey, 1953
- Bob Schaulat, 1955
- Terry Bethel, 1956, 1957
- Tom Jackson, 1957
- Ernie Wilhoit, 1958
- Bogie Redmon, 1961
- Fred Riddle, 1961
- Rodger Bohnenstiehl, 1962, 1963, 1964
- Dennis Pace, 1965
- Tom Parker, 1966, 1967, 1968
- Jerry Ahart, 1970
- Bob Shapiro, 1970
- Richard Knarr, 1972
- Bobby Bone, 1973
- Marc Fletcher, 1974
- Joe Ossola, 1977
- Kevin Stallings, 1977, 1978
- John Belobraydic, 1978
- Steve Ray, 1978
- Gary Kerkemeyer, 1979
- Bill Mosier, 1980
- Jim McConkey, 1982
- Richard Keene, 1991, 1992
- Corey Garcia, 1995
- Terry Tessary, 2001
- Daryn Foster, 2012
- Ray'Sean Taylor, 2020
|